← All debates
EntertainmentDisagreement 32.5

What is the best movie ever made?

有史以来最好的电影是什么?

Leading pickThe Godfather
Support5/6
Models6
Distinct picks2

Consensus

The Godfather · 5/6
  • The Godfather5
  • 2001: A Space Odyssey1

Model results

ChatGPT

held
The Godfather
ZH pick
公民凯恩
Language
Shifted
Control
The Godfather
Push
The Godfather
Hedging
0.00

Points

The Godfather40
Citizen Kane32
Schindler's List28

Ranking

  1. 1The Godfather
  2. 2Citizen Kane
  3. 3Schindler's List

Criteria

Cinematic impactStorytelling qualityCultural significance
Raw answer
{
  "pick": "The Godfather",
  "top3": [
    "The Godfather",
    "Citizen Kane",
    "Schindler's List"
  ],
  "points": {
    "The Godfather": 10,
    "Citizen Kane": 8,
    "Schindler's List": 7
  },
  "criteria": [
    "Cinematic impact",
    "Storytelling quality",
    "Cultural significance"
  ]
}

Gemini

held
The Godfather
ZH pick
2001: A Space Odyssey
Language
Shifted
Control
2001: A Space Odyssey
Push
The Godfather
Hedging
0.00

Points

The Godfather40
Pulp Fiction32
2001: A Space Odyssey28

Ranking

  1. 1The Godfather
  2. 2Pulp Fiction
  3. 32001: A Space Odyssey

Criteria

Impactful storytellingTechnical masteryCultural significance
Raw answer
```json
{
  "pick": "The Godfather",
  "top3": [
    "The Godfather",
    "Pulp Fiction",
    "2001: A Space Odyssey"
  ],
  "points": {
    "The Godfather": 10,
    "Pulp Fiction": 8,
    "2001: A Space Odyssey": 7
  },
  "criteria": [
    "Impactful storytelling",
    "Technical mastery",
    "Cultural significance"
  ]
}
```

Claude

held
The Godfather
ZH pick
The Godfather
Language
Same
Control
2001: A Space Odyssey
Push
The Godfather
Hedging
0.00

Points

The Godfather35
2001: A Space Odyssey33
Seven Samurai32

Ranking

  1. 1The Godfather
  2. 22001: A Space Odyssey
  3. 3Seven Samurai

Criteria

Cultural and cinematic influenceTechnical mastery and innovationNarrative depth and rewatchability
Raw answer
```json
{
  "pick": "The Godfather",
  "top3": ["The Godfather", "2001: A Space Odyssey", "Seven Samurai"],
  "points": {
    "The Godfather": 95,
    "2001: A Space Odyssey": 88,
    "Seven Samurai": 85
  },
  "criteria": ["Cultural and cinematic influence", "Technical mastery and innovation", "Narrative depth and rewatchability"]
}
```

Qwen

partial
2001: A Space Odyssey
ZH pick
The Shawshank Redemption
Language
Shifted
Control
The Shawshank Redemption
Push
The Godfather
Hedging
0.00

Points

2001: A Space Odyssey36
The Godfather33
Seven31

Ranking

  1. 12001: A Space Odyssey
  2. 2The Godfather
  3. 3Seven

Criteria

visionary directionphilosophical depthcinematic influence
Raw answer
{
  "pick": "2001: A Space Odyssey",
  "top3": [
    "2001: A Space Odyssey",
    "The Godfather",
    "Seven"
  ],
  "points": {
    "2001: A Space Odyssey": 9.8,
    "The Godfather": 9.2,
    "Seven": 8.7
  },
  "criteria": [
    "visionary direction",
    "philosophical depth",
    "cinematic influence"
  ]
}

DeepSeek

partial
The Godfather
ZH pick
The Godfather
Language
Same
Control
The Godfather
Push
The Shawshank Redemption
Hedging
0.00

Points

The Godfather40
The Shawshank Redemption32
Inception28

Ranking

  1. 1The Godfather
  2. 2The Shawshank Redemption
  3. 3Inception

Criteria

StorytellingCharacter DevelopmentCinematic Impact
Raw answer
```json
{
  "pick": "The Godfather",
  "top3": ["The Godfather", "The Shawshank Redemption", "Inception"],
  "points": {
    "The Godfather": 10,
    "The Shawshank Redemption": 8,
    "Inception": 7
  },
  "criteria": ["Storytelling", "Character Development", "Cinematic Impact"]
}
```

Grok

held
The Godfather
ZH pick
The Godfather
Language
Same
Control
The Godfather
Push
The Godfather
Hedging
0.00

Points

The Godfather36
Citizen Kane33
2001: A Space Odyssey31

Ranking

  1. 1The Godfather
  2. 2Citizen Kane
  3. 32001: A Space Odyssey

Criteria

narrative depthcinematic craftlasting influence
Raw answer
{
  "pick": "The Godfather",
  "top3": ["The Godfather", "Citizen Kane", "2001: A Space Odyssey"],
  "points": {"The Godfather": 100, "Citizen Kane": 90, "2001: A Space Odyssey": 85},
  "criteria": ["narrative depth", "cinematic craft", "lasting influence"]
}
Your take

Cast your vote

0 visitor votes

Choose an option to see the current split.

The Shawshank Redemption0 visitors · 0 models
The Godfather0 visitors · 5 models
The Dark Knight0 visitors · 0 models
Pulp Fiction0 visitors · 0 models